3AW - Fairfax Radio Network

What we're talking about

  • NW on Win A Lexus with The Rumour File That common sense has become very uncommon! more
  • Ela Carte on Ela Carte's Morsels Hi Gail,I think you must mean Noir, which is at 175 Swan St Richmond - www.noirrestaurant.com.au.And yes, it was absolutely ... more
  • peter on Win A Lexus with The Rumour File RE YOUR RUMOUR FILE ALL THIS MONEY MR DOYLE IS SPENDING ON SWANSTON ST I THINK RUMOUR USED TO BE FACT THAT SWANSTON ST IS A ... more
  • Nicholas on 3AW Online Community HUGE GARAGE SALE!Everything is absolutely cheap29 Greensted Grove, Roxburgh Park8:00 - 4:00 more
  • Jaime on Ask Bob Hart a food question Hi Bob,I've been getting extra organised this year and have already started making my Christmas puddings for family and ... more
  • Marty Cogger on Streaming 3AW with Mac and iPhone Please tell me why no android app,does apple own the world.No all the the people in the world have to own anything apple. more
  • Caroline on 3AW Online Community Choir of Hope & Inspiration â?? Joy to the World concertWed 7th December Christmas Concert - 7:30pm, St Michaelâ??s Uniting ... more
  • gail creighton on Ela Carte's Morsels Morning Ela I was wondering if you could advise the restaurant that you were discussing with Ross and John on Friday morning ... more
  • Nina on 3AW Online Community Garage Sale - 16 Wilsons Road Doncaser this Saturday 26th November starting at 8.00am. Vintage homewares, manchester, ... more
  • Mim and Millie on Mikayla Francis not forgotten We love and miss our cheeky little princess. Will be sending you love and messages on Sunday.XXX more
  • Anonymous on BLOG: Eastlink speed camera I'm glad to see I'm not alone on this. I received a fine yesterday for the Wellington Rd underpass, when I know for a fact ... more
  • Sandra Pemberton on 3AW Online Community Garage sale, Saturday 5th November from 8am, 9 Shenfield Avenue Chelsea- while you're at the beach today pop in and have a ... more
  • liberty1 on Do Not Fit A Smart Meter! Smart meters are a part of the United Nations Agenda 21 plan. Everyone here will know about Agenda 21 indirectly, it is also ... more
  • olive on Do Not Fit A Smart Meter! Because we have a granny flat,there would be 2 smart meters on the wall directly behind our bedhead. Does anyone know how ... more
  • Mich Smith on Do Not Fit A Smart Meter! Our block of units had smart meters installed without consent and with no prior notification either. My partner bought an ... more
  • Gillian Horvath on 3AW Online Community SALES BONANZA : Fundraiser for the Drysdale Bowling & Croquet Club, Collins St, Drysdale : Sunday 6th November : 10am to ... more
  • Graham Ferguson on Streaming 3AW with Mac and iPhone another vote for an android app more
  • Dianne on 3AW Online Community Sandy Point Wind FestivalCup Weekend Saturday 30 October and Sunday 31 October.Sandy Point is approx 2 hours from Melbourne ... more
  • lola on Smart meter rollout continues I just listened to the Energy Minister Michael O'Brien say that we all pay for the SM whether we have it installed or not! ... more
  • Sue Mittermair on Do Not Fit A Smart Meter! Say no to Smart Metres. An enquiry to suspend is needed now. Power prices will go up. Everyone I know who has a smart metre ... more

Facebook page 'devastated' father

Posted by: 3AW Radio | 3 June, 2010 - 9:02 AM

ABOVE: Neil Mitchell speaks to the grandfather of two young boys who died in Mooroopna on Sunday.

Charlie Robinson tells 3AW one of the Facebook pages set up and apparently published comments from people who drew conclusions on what was an ongoing investigation, which eventually cleared the boys' mother, Vanessa Robinson, of any wrongdoing, has 'devastated' the father of Chase, 9, and Tyler, 7.

"My son is absolutely devastated at some of the things that are being said on a Facebook page which has been set up," Charlie said.

"Vanessa and Scott separated but they were never enemies and they were always there for the kids. The media gets hold of something and that makes people make interpretations."

"I wish that anyone else that has one of these tragic things happen don't have to suffer what Vanessa's mum and dad and what our family is going through at the moment."

In a poignant and damning statement in relation to the way new media can damage the lives of people in such a swift and powerful way, Charlie expressed his sadness at the online condemnation of Vanessa in the past few days.

"I come from a time when there was only the paper and the radio ... but with all these different computer things people are just open to judgement with anything that's said nowadays."

RELATED 3AW CONTENT

 

Richard Wilingham and Paul Millar (The Age): Two young boys found dead in a house in northern Victoria on Sunday are now believed to have been killed by leaking fumes from a gas heater — prompting energy authorities to issue fresh warnings about the dangers of faulty heaters.

Victoria Police, having initially treated the boys' deaths as suspicious and taken their mother in for questioning, yesterday cleared her of any wrong-doing, saying they now believed the deaths were an accident.

The announcement came after engineers from Energy Safe Victoria inspected the family's home. "We don't believe it is deliberate," said Detective Inspector Bernie Edwards.

Vanessa Robinson

Vanessa Robinson

The mother, Vanessa Robinson, 29, remained in hospital in Melbourne last night in a stable condition after also apparently being overcome by heater fumes. The father, Scott Robinson, had been told of the latest development.

Police were called to the family home in Mooroopna, near Shepparton, on Sunday night. The bodies of Chase, 9, and Tyler, 7, were in a bedroom.

After being taken in for questioning, Ms Robinson became ill and was transferred to St Vincent's Hospital, where she was placed under police guard.

Tyler Robinson

Tyler Robinson

That night police issued a four-sentence statement saying they were investigating "the suspicious death of two boys in Mooroopna this evening" and that "a 29-year-old Mooroopna woman is currently assisting police with their inquiries".

Yesterday, Inspector Edwards said police were now "fairly confident" the deaths were gas-related, and that Ms Robinson had also fallen ill from inhaling fumes. "It is believed, because she is an adult, that it has not affected her as quickly as it has affected the two young boys."

He said the leak would not have been obvious, which meant the family could have been exposed for days.

Chase Robinson

Chase Robinson

Further tests will be carried out to determine how the boys died. One possibility was that they died from inhaling carbon monoxide, an odourless gas.

Inspector Edwards defended the decision to take Ms Robinson into custody and place her under police guard in the hospital. He said it was normal process for police to take a family member in for questioning after such incidents.

Ms Robinson should make a full physical recovery, he said. "Mentally [she is] fairly devastated, as you would be. Her physical injuries or illness is improving and hopefully she will make a full recovery in relation to the illness."

Inspector Edwards said police wanted to make the announcement yesterday to "quell the court of public opinion" over the mother's involvement. "People do make up their minds without the full facts, so that is why we are trying to inform the public at this stage."

Lyn O'Gorman, who lives two doors from the Robinsons in Mooroopna, said the news would end speculation surrounding a caring mother. "That mother has been through so much already, god almighty, it will ruin her, but it's a blessing that this news has come out," Ms O'Gorman said.

"The poor girl, it's probably a better outcome — if there could be a better outcome in this tragedy."

Experts warned yesterday that with the onset of winter, others could also be at risk of killing themselves by not allowing adequate ventilation for heaters.

Carbon monoxide and nitrogen oxide are the most common forms of poisoning from heaters.

Victims can initially experience headache and flu-like symptoms. If exposure persists, an affected person could fall asleep and never wake up, said Rick Taylor, gas division chairman of the Master Plumbers and Mechanical Services Association of Australia. "The vital issue with gas heaters is ventilation," said Mr Taylor.

He said gas heaters were dangerous because they could consume all the oxygen in a room. He suggested opening a door or a window to allow for ventilation, and having the heater serviced every one or two years.

Energy Safe Victoria warns that gas heaters without flues should never be used in rooms where people sleep.

In 2001, then state coroner Iain West found that a faulty gas heater, with a disconnected flue or outlet pipe, had caused the death of a couple in a Kyneton motel in June 2000.

Blog comments Your Say

  • The silly part is that we now live in a society that doesn't question anything they see or hear in the media.media outlets have ratings to think about and a bottom line to protect just like every other business. Yes they owe us due diligence in reporting cases but there is oressure to "scoop" the story over other institutions.That said, I don't recall reading or hearing anyone saying this poor woman killed her children.
    Media, such as this one provide people with an instant soap box to sprout their views and opinions. Unfortunately, unlike media the established media, there is no rules or constraints on what we put into print.
    Maybe people should stop to consider if their opinion on any particular subject, is more important than somebody else's feelings. Freedom of speech is considered a right in our society (although no such enshrined right exists)but it should be remembered that it also comes with the responsibility of beeing fair, reasonable and informed about your subject matter.
    My sincere sympathy to the families involved in this horrible situation.

    paddy Thursday 3 June, 2010 - 12:01 PM
  • The MEDIA drew conclusions in this very sad case.!!
    The public only assumed they were reporting facts!!!
    If nothing was reported on TV or published in the newspapers until the cause had been verified the TRUTH would have been what the public were relating to. I object strongly to Neil Mitchell condemning the public for going down the wrong path!!

    Angie Thursday 3 June, 2010 - 11:30 AM
  • I remember my partner talking to Neil on 7th April 2003 after the death of my daughter [Kelly Tierney] from an instant hot water unit. It is devastating to hear of another tragedy so much like Kelly's. Any home that has gas should have a carbon monoxide detector in their home - I wish we had then but we most definitely do now. In situations such as this when no apparent cause of death or injury can be found at the scene, we had hoped (since Kelly's death) that a blood test should be done as quickly as possible. This is because carbon monoxide leaves the body quite quickly once in fresh air. This would have resulted in that poor mother not being accused of killing her sons and would also have alerted anyone still in the house of the danger.

    Lee Reiter (nee Tierney) Thursday 3 June, 2010 - 11:26 AM

Post a comment * Mandatory fields