3AW - Fairfax Radio Network

What we're talking about

  • David THomas on 'The figures say it all' Statistical evidence mounts that the police often do not recruit the sharpest pencils in the box. Seriously. Turn the ... more
  • John on 'The figures say it all' This is not about fairness, it is about deflecting responsibility. The camera system should conform to vehicles operating ... more
  • Paul on 'The figures say it all' Have a look at the front of any modern bike and you will quickly see why it is not possible to put a front plate on. There ... more
  • CHRIS WATTS on 'The figures say it all' i just cannot believe that a simple e tag cannot be stuck on the front of the bike...its so simple, surely... more
  • Samuel J on 'The figures say it all' Motor cycles should have front and rear number plates. The notion that front number plates dissect pedestrians is complete ... more
  • Mark on 'The figures say it all' All a bit of a joke, here in Europe, bikes get a much larger rear plate... more than double the size. Aussies often hide the ... more
  • Richard on 'The figures say it all' If its such a problem why are the Penisula Link cameras facing the front? The fault is in the camera system. more
  • Tom Bysen on 'The figures say it all' Why not ban bikes altogether? We can all sit jammed on the freeway, in our 2tonne suv's being safe. more
  • John Karmouche on 'The figures say it all' Everyone is barking up the wrong tree. Its not about putting a number plate on a motorcycle- that's the cover story the ... more
  • Lukew on 'The figures say it all' Commissioner Gordon Lewis can huff and puff all he likes but this is about the money. Never mind the doubt, why would we ... more
  • poppitt on 'The figures say it all' Against the law to ride a bike that does have number plates back and front. Fine them $500 for each plate that is not ... more
  • Time for a career change Neil on 'The figures say it all' Gee, it must be almost the 3rd week of the month. Time for Neil to roll out the anti motorcycle vitriol again. The same ... more
  • Otto on 'The figures say it all' Anything to justify the cash cows, how many of these thousands of lethal speeding motorcycles actually result in a fatality ... more
  • Gazza on Top cop concerned over pokies gang Multiculturalism at its finest more
  • dom on Spot the 'ghost'? Sorry the line for popcorn was long... more
  • Rory on Spot the 'ghost'? Why do ghosts always have clothes on? I wonder if a tradie has to wear Hi-Viz if they get a ghost. more
  • charles on Spot the 'ghost'? I see an elderly lady old white shirt, black hair, pale skin sitting at the top of staircase, peering to the right as if ... more
  • Rhees on Spot the 'ghost'? I can see through the railings.Enlarge picture and take a close look, definitely something there.One place i worked at ... more
  • Anne of Dallas on Spot the 'ghost'? Well.. I cant see the ghost.. but I did learn something fabulous from one of the readers in comment! "Enlarge for a better ... more
  • Joanne on Spot the 'ghost'? Enlarge for a better look. To enlarge the photo if using a computer: press control and the plus button at the same time more

David Galbally QC's red light fine letter

Posted by: David Galbally | 5 October, 2012 - 10:45 AM
Red light fine letter

Leading Australian QC David Galbally has provided 3AW listeners with the following template letter to send to the Minister for Roads and the Department of Justice  if they believe they have been wrongly fined by dodgy red-light cameras.


Dept of Justice
GPO Box 4356  
Melbourne VIC 3000




To the Minister for Roads and the Department of Justice,

On the [insert date] I was fined [$ insert details] for proceeding through a red light situated on [insert details of road/street] of [insert details of suburb]. 

It has now become apparent that the red light camera was not correctly calibrated and I should not have been fined.  [**If the writer has lost their licence - add the following - **Furthermore, as a consequence of paying the fine, I received demerit points resulting in my loss of licence.  The loss of licence has caused me financial loss which can only be attributed to the failure of the red light camera to operate properly.]

Please advise as to what steps you are taking to refund the fine, remove my demerit points and compensate me for the loss caused as a consequence of a demerit point being recorded against my licence.

In the event that you do not respond within 14 days, I will have no alternative but to look to my legal rights.

Yours faithfully,

[Insert details]



Thousands of red-light fines in doubt

Millions of dollars in fines & thousands of demerit points are in doubt after a state government audit of red light cameras. VICROADS: The validity of thousands of red light camera fines are being questioned following an audit. Last month the Rumour File revealed Altona Meadows man Gordon Bishop had challenged a red light camera fine in court and won. Details here.

'Vicroads have conned motorists'

<b>RUMOUR FILE CONFIRMED:</b> Red light fine overturned. NEIL MITCHELL: Vicroads has known about this since January this year and they didn’t tell anybody. Now they were forced into an audit they should have done almost a year ago. They have been slow, incompetent and misleading to motorists.

Blog comments Your Say

  • @ Dan Connelly,

    You wouldn't have lost your licence just for one red light ticket. You were obviously just a poor driver to have racked up so many points already. There are driving courses you can do to improve.

    Peter Hillster Monday 12 November, 2012 - 7:07 AM
  • I was aledgely caught at Doncaster and Williamsons rd intercection, missed my due date to respond for option 1 and lost my licence for 3 months. I have since been paying $200 a day for a drive as i am self employed and needed to get to jobs.
    So thanks for your input here

    Dan Connolly Friday 9 November, 2012 - 2:17 PM
  • Has anyone had a response to their letter yet? The letter states that after 14days legal action will be taken. We're still waiting.

    Pat Cavalot Friday 9 November, 2012 - 9:47 AM
  • Hi Neil
    As with Vince I was caught at the intersection of Williamson Road and Doncaster Road on 14 Nov 2011. I knew something was wrong so asked for the photographs from Civic Compliance and then wrote a letter to them. I eventually paid, not before videoing the traffic lights and comparing with other major intersections. I to wanted to go to court but told process too hard. Can you please also provide me with the relevent address for the Minister of Roads and Dept of Justice.
    Keep up the good work - I also will get an apology from my wife who says I am a steed merchant which I am not. I had 0 demerit points, now have 3

    Andrew Monday 22 October, 2012 - 1:24 PM
  • Thanks,Neil for a stirling job.
    I was nabbed at the intersection of Doncaster Rd.and Willimsons Rd.during that period.I was convinced that I had not committed the offence,but felt it a waste of time appealing against it.The time on the red was deemed to be 1.5 seconds.
    Could you please post the address for the Minister for Roads and the Dept.of Justice
    Much Appreciated

    Vince O' Connor Friday 19 October, 2012 - 5:33 PM
  • Thanks so much for providing the letter and information as to how to deal with these red light infringements.

    I was drafting my own when i found your template online.

    What a Gentleman!!

    Romy Hendel Thursday 11 October, 2012 - 10:02 PM

Post a comment * Mandatory fields