3AW - Fairfax Radio Network

What we're talking about

  • Jack Chang on Ballcourt Hotel Has this hotel changed hand recently, freehold and business or just business? They had an auction sometime last year but no ... more
  • Graham on Manhattan Hotel, Ringwood You are totally right Tony. Pubs in the burbs have focussed too much on bright lights, brass & silver fittings, poker ... more
  • Janet Willson on Mount Macedon Hotel Thanks for your great sharing of Mount Macedon Hotel. I like this. more
  • brighton pub on Grosvenor Hotel I will definitely visit this pub atleast once as its a rare pub beacon in the southern suburbs. more
  • Sav on Glenferrie Hotel Hi we have never been to your pub however we are wanting to have a family Easter lunch for approximately 20 people ??One ... more
  • kathy Mcintyre-Davidson on Review: Millers Inn Love the Millers ! Have been away from Melbourne for 20 years and that place still serves the best t-bone steak!! more
  • Kelley on New release movie reviews - November 8 Grant is portrayed as a saint, which is misleading and manipulative. The message this film sends to the black community is ... more
  • kg on New release movie reviews - November 8 I disagree with the review on Fruitvale. Oscar's flaws were obvious and uncomfortable. The manager who denies him his job ... more
  • Heath on REVIEW: Union Hotel Yes. In the union at the moment. Love this place. Not surprised to learn its owned by the same people as the standard. ... more
  • peter michelsz on Ballcourt Hotel can anyone tell me what last weeks pub of the week was 26-7-2013 more
  • Vera on Plough Hotel We enjoyed a lunch at this hotel last weekend, the place was packed (a good sign).Fourteen of us had lovely meals which ... more
  • Bill on Pub of the Week 2013: The search ... Hello Tony,Recently I had the nicest surprise I have ever endured I attended a private function at the Spotswood Hotel well ... more
  • Jeff on Pub of the Week 2013: The search ... Tony, The popular Zorka and Volbi are back at The Orrong Hotel - 709 High st Armadale (they sold North Fitzroy Arms)! Yes, ... more
  • Shane W on Pine Grove Hotel How long have these 2 pubs been on the website? more
  • Bill Graham on Pub of the Week 2013: The search ... You really MUST try The Snug Public House, 68 Sydney Road, Brunswick.... Kim and Michael are building one hell of an eating ... more
  • tony on Lord Newry Hotel we do sunday lunch and i must say the rose hotel was one of the best keep it up more
  • Shane W on Prahran Hotel How come this page hasn't been updated for weeks? Looking forward to more reviews. more
  • IAN on Pub of the Week 2013: The search ... Tony ???Still none in the Pakenham-Dandenong- Cranbourne- Rowville.??area To far for the "MAN" who travels by Train. more
  • michele on Woodlands Hotel Absolutly fabulous pub went there wednesday for a curryand a pot/cider for $15 food great service excellent and decore ... more

Railway Hotel

Posted by: Tony Leonard | 14 November, 2012 - 3:54 PM

Pub:                       Railway Hotel
Where:                 29 Chapel St., Windsor
Phone:                 95104050
Date:                     19 October 2012
Score:                   14/20
Internet:              www.therailway.com.au


A massive two storey pub near the Dandenong Rd end of Chapel St, all the action regarding food and drink takes place on their thoroughly modern first floor that packs a punch in a rather limited space.

With the most beautiful view of the Melbourne skyline from their first floor, (just follow the train tracks back to town overlooking Windsor station), the Railway offers a heady mix of food, drink and good times and cannily completes the act of appealing to old (me) and young (you).

The Railway has had a stunning fit-out; there’s space for functions, cocktail classes, disco, but on the first floor, there is a 50:50 split in space for indoor/courtyard dining and on a brilliant Sunday, the pub was full and the music was going full tilt (acceptable even for me).

And what they get right here is that there first and foremost function is to run it as a “pub” rather than “venue”; the food is clever, well thought out, pub grub, and a good selection of wines comes from a limited list.

Fundamental to any pub is the draught beer; here it was wonderful, clean and best of all, the glassware had been properly treated.  Table service, friendly staff, the Railway has a good team driving the ship and to me, appear to genuinely enjoy working there.

To top it all off, the Railway has a menu item that I haven’t encountered before.  So simple, so smart and so brilliantly presented; potato cakes.

$4.50 for 3, garlic aioli, hot, golden. Even re-canting this, an image of Homer Simpson appears.

Mmmmm, potato cakes.


Entrees:               Not really, save for the aforesaid potato cakes.
Mains:                  $24
Desserts:             $10
Wine:                    $38


Functions/bottle shop (24 hour) is the street level offer. In common with the Flower Drum, there is a lift that takes you to the first floor if you don’t wish to take the stairs.  And this is where the action takes place.

The rectangular bar greets you, and what is a seamless structure, it extends into the open face kitchen. The food leaving the galley looks impressive; simply you want to buy.

If I have a quibble, it is that smoking is allowed in the courtyard where people dine.  For sure you know that (and is permissable), so if that doesn’t suit you eat inside (no leeching of smoke in there).

Pizza is a staple of pub life now so you if you charge $18, there should be a point of difference.  At the Railway, there is a proscuitto, gorgonzola, pear, rocket (21) or pine nut, caramelised onion, roasted pumpkin, gorgonzola (18) for your consideration.

The pub staples are the go - 4 pastas including a linguine of pancetta, olives, tomato, chilli, rocket, red onion (21), big burger with the trimmings (23) or a maybe  a platter of BBQ’d meats for 4 people  (45) or seafood (55) if you go as a group.

I like generous mid-week “local” specials; the Railway is no exception.  A 350g porterhouse, and glass of Shiraz from Heathcote sets you back a friendly $22 on Tuesdays; an express lunch from a set menu plus drink is $16.  Good.

And with that view on a balmy, warm Melbourne summers day/night back to town for free, there’s a value add to the Railway that few pubs can match.


- Potato Cakes - 3 for $4.50 with garlic aoili.  Made in the kitchen, fluffy and hot inside, golden brown outside. One seriously simple, smart dish.

- Beer battered king george whiting fillets, thick chips, tartare - $23. Fresh, white fillets, (3), served hot, great taste, just the  perfect amount. And the proper fish used.

- Panko Crumbed chicken breast, vietnamese coleslaw - $23. Normally I’m a no go for CB, but this thick, moist breast in Japanese breadcrumbs, aided by the coleslaw (lot of mint through it) ended up a ripper pub dish,

- Mr. Riggs Watervale Riesling - $38//$8/glass.    No problems there.


An extra tick goes to the railway for having its website up to date. I recommend having a look and the images really sell the pub in the most positive manner.

In a most curious juxtaposition, the Railway finds itself now at the more glamorous end of Chapel St, away (if  it’s possible) from the hustle and bustle.

Its offer matches matches its environs; cool enough for those who want that, traditional for people like me wanting a place of food and drink.

Well worth a visit.

Blog comments Your Say

Post a comment * Mandatory fields