Thanks for logging in.

You can now click/tap WATCH to start the live stream.

Thanks for logging in.

You can now click/tap LISTEN to start the live stream.

Thanks for logging in.

You can now click/tap LATEST NEWS to start the live stream.

on air now

Create a 3AW account today!

You can now log in once to listen live, watch live, join competitions, enjoy exclusive 3AW content and other benefits.

Joining is free and easy.

You will soon need to register to keep streaming 3AW online. Register an account or skip for now to do it later.


Jim Schembri’s new release movie reviews. 20 Nov. Plus Robert Redford’s top 25 films

Jim Schembri
Article image for Jim Schembri’s new release movie reviews. 20 Nov. Plus Robert Redford’s top 25 films



SPITFIRE ***1/2 (99 minutes) PG

The evolution of the legendary Spitfire fighter and the crucial role it played in pushing back against the might of Hitler’s Wehrmacht – which had already conquered the skies of Europe – is chronicled in this dutifully crafted tribute. War buffs will love it.

Featuring a mix of archival footage and interviews with veterans, all tied together with a narration by Charles Dance, it’s a conventional package, yet a rousing one.

Having subdued most of Europe in a very short time, Hitler’s eyes turned towards England, confident that his huge air power would make short work of whatever antiquated jalopies the Royal Air Force had, especially given that his was several times larger, far more advanced and battle hardened.

England turned out to be a tad more prepared as the Spitfire helped fend off wave after wave of increasingly determined German planes, ultimately stemming the tide of Hitler’s advance.

There’s plenty of detail to marvel over, the brightest nugget being how the Spitfire’s wing design was nicked by a British designer who was inspired while working in Germany before the war.

With the rapidly shifting demands on the plane, huge teams of designers, with women prominent amongst them, kept developing the plane until, by war’s end, there were no fewer than 25 models.

The role women served in designing, building and delivering the Spitfire is given plenty of attention, with one veteran getting the surprise of her life when she is reunited with one of the country’s few surviving planes.

Of note, too, is how the huge loss of pilots suffered by the RAF and the physically punishing grind of combat is offset somewhat by the open admission by some vets that fun was a large part of their war experience. We also saw this come up in the WW1 documentary They Shall Not Grow Old, suggesting that humanity can triumph even when enveloped by the horror of war.

Now, any war buff or aviation nut will no doubt feel an odd mixture of elation and frustration with this film. For while it is a worthy, informative and entertaining tribute to the Spitfire, the claims of the plane’s importance during the war will, quite understandably, be met with objections. What about other fighters, such as the Mustang P-51?

The film does fleetingly acknowledge the place of other planes in the pantheon of great WW2 fighters – the eternally underrated Hawker Hurricane gets a mention, as do the German fighters that challenged the power of the Spitfire – but, to be fair, had the film gone off on tangents it would have cost the documentary its focus.

Buffs aside, young filmgoers should get a lot out of this film, primarily for chronicling the first time in history where mastery of the air became a critical part of any large-scale military operation, a lesson the Americans quickly learnt after the Japanese paid a visit to Pearl Harbour.



The second of five intended installments to the Harry Potter sub-franchise is, to be honest, an ornate, expensive-looking, visually dull slog.

The downcast and uncharismatic Newt Scamander (Eddie Redmayne, who won an Oscar for The Theory of Everything) is recruited to track down and capture the evil Gellert Grindelwald (Johnny Depp), who has escaped from prison.

His plan is to gather recruits to his cause of having “pure-bloods” rule the worlds of wizards  and mortals, invoking the language and gestures of Hitler who, though not directly referenced in the film, was on the rise at the time the film is set.

Now, you know how sometimes with cordial concentrate you find a few drops at the bottom of an otherwise empty container and you think “I bet there’s just enough here for another glass” but you find after adding water that there wasn’t and that though you can still faintly taste the flavour it’s basically just an unsatisfying glass of water? Well, Fantastic Beasts II is the cinematic equivalent of that experience.

With a $200 million budget it sure is supposed to look impressive, with huge sets and swirling effects, but – Heaven help us – here is yet another big film that looks just that same as a stack of others. Eternally overcast and dimly lit, there are no fresh idea here, just more swirling bolts of lightning and critters that look as though they’ve escaped from Middle Earth.

Worse still, you can really feel the strain in the film’s laboured storytelling.

Written by HP creator JK Rowling and directed by David Yates, who did the previous FB film plus the final four HP films, the movie stands as a monument to sequel padding, as evident by the inordinate amount of back-stories and side-stories there are. They’re all over the place and damned annoying. It’s as though they’re trying to fill in the many blanks in the narrative and build up enough narrative builk to drive the next chapter.

This accounts for the film’s sluggish pace, which, frankly, is often quite boring with its wearying stop-start, two-steps-forward, one step-back momentum.

And while there’s no argument JK Rowling is a brilliant, hyper-successful novelist, her screen-writing skills might need a lot of sharpening up if her first two efforts are any guide. Inspired direction would have helped, but Yates is clearly in auto-pilot mode.

The key symptom of this is how, beyond the clumsy story-telling and pedestrian direction, is the moribund central performance by Redmayne. He simply fails to bring much light or life to Newt. If only one of the energy bolts or magical wisps flying around in the film would strike him in the keester and liven up his character a tad.

As is the tradition with post-content cinema in the 21st century, the marketing tsunami behind the film will likely get the box office numbers it needs to justify a third entry into this  far-from-compelling sub-franchise.

Or maybe not. We can only pray.


THE OLD MAN WITH THE GUN ***1/2 (94 minutes) M

Although the message that “crime doesn’t pay” presides over the crime movie genre, we are, nonetheless, often invited to side with criminals, to see the world from their point of view and even to like them despite what they do.

Veteran actor Robert Redford, now 82, has starred in more than his fair share of films where his on-screen deeds are at odds with his likeability – The Hot Rock, The Last Castle, Sneakers, Indecent Proposal, The Candidate, etc – and his latest triumph, The Old Man With the Gun, slips neatly into line.

Set in the 1980s and based (mostly) on a true story, Redford plays Forrest Tucker, an extremely genial, smartly dressed old fellow who makes a very handsome living robbing banks in between his stints in prison, which he has become a master at breaking out of.

His robbery method is as simple as it is effective: he simply walks into a bank, hands the teller or manager a note informing them that they are being robbed, opens his coat to show them his gun – always off screen – then kindly and quietly gets them to fill his suitcase with cash.

With no violence, no shooting, not even a raised voice, but always with a smile, he then leaves the bank, walks to his car and drives off.

On his tail is Detective John Hunt (Casey Affleck, in a terrific, subdued turn), who is almost as charmed by Tucker as Jewel (Sissy Spacek putting in a fabulously natural performance), a woman who falls under Tucker’s spell, and with whom he forms a strong – and rare – emotional attachment.

With his elderly accomplices (Tom Waits and Danny Glover) in tow, he engages on a well-publicised crime spree. They are promptly dubbed the “Over the Hill Gang” and instantly become media darlings.

Director David Lowery has gone to a lot of trouble replicating the grainy look and filming styles of the period, including the movie music and graphics of the time. His chief focus, nonetheless, is to keep the character of Forrest Tucker within the popular perception of Redford’s persona – the handsome, ever-likeable loner. And it works, both as a light crimedy and as a valentine to Redford.

Much has been made of Redford’s claim that this will be his final film as an actor. If that’s true, he’s gone out on a high – to his credit, Redford doesn’t have the underside of bad films on his CV that most people of his vintage do – but, thankfully and predictably, he has since qualified that statement, especially in terms of directing more movies.

Though his latter-life directing efforts can’t match the sweet spot Clint Eastwood, 88, has found, Redford has helmed some fine films, such as Lions for Lambs, The Company You Keep and – yes – The Horse Whisperer (it grows on you over time!).

Longevity seems to be one of the perks of being part of Old Hollywood and Redford has never been known to willfully waste anyone’s time, especially his own.

Born in 1936, Redford hit Hollywood via TV in 1962. It didn’t take long for him to look beyond the appeal of his good looks and work for something deeper in film.

The star of such classics as The Sting, Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid and Out of Africa, Redford also harnessed an independent filmmaking spirit early in his career that lead to his founding of the world-famous Sundance Institute, to which generations of up-and-coming filmmakers owe their careers.

Now 82, Redford’s filmography is a formidable legacy of value-driven, character based work. His most recent films as actor, such as All is Lost, and director, such as The Company You Keep, show how his instincts for strong stories with challenging themes and topical material are as sharp as ever, making the idea that he would retire even more implausible.

Here is a selective list of Redford’s 25 best films, spanning his career, and including one or two lesser known works.


THIS PROPERTY IS CONDEMNED (1966) After his attention-stealing debut in 1965’s Inside Daisy Clover, Redford proved he was no fluke as the love interest of established star Natalie Wood in this bittersweet Southern steamer. It was his first of many collaborations with director Sydney Pollack.

BAREFOOT IN THE PARK (1967) His winning performance as the hapless partner opposite rising star Jane Fonda in this Neil Simon smash about young love proved Redford could make women laugh as well as provide them with eye candy.

BUTCH CASSIDY AND THE SUNDANCE KID (1969) A classic western – some would argue anti-western for its lyrical style and odd use of music – this is the film that made Redford a star. But he was far from the first choice as Paul Newman’s partner: Steve McQueen, Jack Lemmon, Marlon Brando and Warren Beatty were all approached first before director George Roy Hill defeated studio objections to casting the charismatic up-and-comer.

DOWNHILL RACER (1969) Working with TV director Michael Ritchie, Redford cites this as his first examination of the American drive to win. As producer, he also credits the film – his first foray into independent cinema – with planting the seed for Sundance.

LITTLE FAUSS AND BIG HALSY (1970) Virtually unknown to all but the most hardcore Redford fans, this downbeat film by director Sidney J Furie cast Redford as an unlikeable womanising motorcycle racer opposite the diminutive Michael J Pollard. Though it is one of his most impressive and textured early performances, Redford never really returned to the nastiness he showed here so vividly.

JEREMIAH JOHNSON (1972) As the titular mountain man exacting revenge on the native Americans who killed his family, this visually stunning film (directed by Pollack) became a touchstone for the conflicted Americana Redford would later explore as a director.

THE CANDIDATE (1972) Redford’s second collaboration with Ritchie produced one of the best films of his career, a stinging political satire about a low-level liberal do-gooder recruited to lose an election. Redford’s final post-victory line – “What do we do now?” – has become a classic quote, signifying a man barely in control of the power he has just achieved.

THE HOT ROCK (1972) As a jewel thief driven by more than greed in Peter Yates’ winning crime comedy, Redford dialled down his star status to meld into a killer ensemble that included George Segal, Ron Leibman, Moses Gunn and Zero Mostel. Not a hit but still a gem. The film was made while the Twin Towers were still being built, visible in the helicopter scene.

THE STING (1973) Re-teaming with Butch director George Roy Hill, writer William Goodman and co-star Newman, Redford gave heart to a monstrously popular and stylish crime-revenge comedy that still ranks as one of the most popular ever made. And who could forget that theme?

THE WAY WE WERE (1973) Opposite Barbra Streisand and in the wake of Love Story (1971), Redford shone as a romantic lead. Another hugely successful collaboration with Pollack.

THE GREAT GATSBY (1974) Redford rose above the workman-like direction of Jack Clayton as the enigmatic protagonist of F. Scott Fitzgerald’s classic love/car-crash story. The film didn’t work, but Redford’s casting did.

THREE DAYS OF THE CONDOR (1975) As a low-level CIA researcher, Redford finds himself alone and hunted in a cold New York city, with only his captive Faye Dunaway to keep him warm. Stands alongside The Parallax View and The French Connection as one of the great films of the Nixonian era where paranoia and cynicism reigned.

THE GREAT WALDO PEPPER (1975) Can enemies who faced off in the air over the battlefields of World War I become friends? Redford’s ambitious stunt pilot finds the answer, with the help of an emerging craze called “the movies”. One of his most underrated films, directed by Hill, with great aerial sequences.

ALL THE PRESIDENT’S MEN (1976) Whenever journalists look for positive portrayals of their craft – which are admittedly rare – they look to this film in general and to Redford’s role as investigative reporter Bob Woodward in particular. The one-take scene where he’s scrounging for information on the phone is one of Redford’s proudest moments.

THE ELECTRIC HORSEMAN (1979) Another comedy with Fonda, only this time with a horse, fairy lights and a Las Vegas backdrop. Pollack directed this diverting excursion.

BRUBAKER (1980) What better way to know how to run a prison than to start off as an inmate? Though a dog-whistle at the box office, Redford’s drama about a prison warden trying to do the right thing in the face of systemic corruption remains one of the best films about what being a liberal really means.

OUT OF AFRICA (1985) Meryl Streep wants to tie him down, but Redford’s big-game hunter is more in love with his sense of freedom and the lovely African landscape than he is with her.

SNEAKERS (1992) As the leader of a team of professional computer and security system hackers, this brainy heist comedy was the first film where Redford made fun of the fact he was getting old.

INDECENT PROPOSAL (1993) A million dollars? To spend one night with Robert Redford? Most women would pay for the privilege. That oft-told joke aside, Redford helped Demi Moore and Woody Harrelson give heft to the moral dilemma at the heart of this otherwise cheesy story.

UP CLOSE & PERSONAL (1996) Set in the world of TV news, Redford (playing a producer) and Michelle Pfeiffer (as his star reporter) worked up a good amount of chemistry in their unfairly trashed romantic drama.

THE HORSE WHISPERER (1998) Directing himself as the man who could tame horses with his voice, this was the middle film in Redford’s informal trilogy about the American idyll. The others are A River Runs Though It (1992) and The Legend of Bagger Vance (2000). Think of them as cinematic tone poems to pastoral Americana.

THE NATURAL (1984) All great sports movies use sport as a metaphor for life. The concept might be a tad laboured here, but Redford nonetheless personified the all-American values of resolve and redemption.

LIONS FOR LAMBS (2007) With Tom Cruise, Meryl Streep and a pre-Spider-man Andrew Garfield, Redford directed and starred in this articulate, highly intelligent drama about America’s war on terror. Unfortunately, nobody was interested but it’s still a great, dialogue-driven wrestle with some thorny issues.

ORDINARY PEOPLE (1980) This searing drama about a wealthy family in emotional peril won Redford an Oscar for his directorial debut. We all knew Donald Sutherland was a great actor – but Mary Tyler Moore? Timothy Hutton also picked up a doorstop, as did the film.

QUIZ SHOW (1994) In what is probably his best work as a director, Redford recounts the infamous scandal of the 1950s where game shows were rigged to heighten the drama between contestants. A smooth, increasingly frazzled Ralph Fiennes side-stepped any post-Schindler type-casting with his superb performance as a manipulated winner. The film was a prophecy on the world of reality-TV that was about to hit, and boasted one of the best slug lines of all time: “Fifty million people watched, but no one saw a thing.

…and just one more…

ALL IS LOST (2013)

Stuck in the middle of the ocean on a stricken yacht, Redford is a lost urbanite who must survive everything the sea and sky can throw at him. Directed by JC Chandor (Margin Call; A Most Violent Year), the film is both a great survival story and a declaration that Redford is one of the very few actors who can hold an audience with almost no words and without another soul on the screen.



Jim Schembri